In a word, maybe.
I believe that in American culture, most people simply assume the default setting for a sexual or romantic relationship is monogamy. We're all force-fed a steady diet of spouse-house-kids through the media, pop culture, often family, friends and certainly the work environment. Look at the debate over gay marriage, for example. The opposing side insists "marriage is between one man and one woman" (pardon me while I gag), while most supporters don't even stop to consider the possibility that a non-monogamous relationship is even an option, let alone a valid one. On the rare occasions it's raised as a possibility, it's usually offered up by opponents of same-sex-marriage as part of the "slippery slope" argument (pardon me while I gag again, please), while the even rarer times it's addressed by supporters, it's usually in a "wait your turn" frame of mind.
Look at how many stories center around cheating, its immorality, and its consequences. Hell, I don't think a single daytime soap would still be on the air were it not for the cheating storylines, and most other media falls right in line. So yeah, it's kind of impossible not to "believe" in monogamy-as-default, when our society is clearly set up with that as the norm, or at least the ideal we're all "supposed" to reach for.
On the other hand, I don't really think humans are by nature mate-for-life types. I'm not even convinced most of us are serial-monogamy types, though I'm sure that's more common. Nearly everybody I know who has been in a relationship that was accepted (most times unspokenly) as monogamous has cheated, been cheated on, or both. Once in a while, the relationship is officially opened, which strikes me as a better idea but still not monogamy, and even then can lead to cheating or being cheated on, or both.
So it seems to me that everybody just
assumes that everybody else believes in monogamy, accepts it as right and true and ideal, but not many people can actually practice it. Some couples manage, after much trial and error and usually a forgiven screw-up or two, to navigate monogamy eventually, but it's clearly work. Whether it's work worth doing or not is up to each individual and their relationship.
For myself, I don't believe in relationships at all. I believe that I, personally, will remain as I am and have been for most of the past dozen years----single, with the occasional friends-with-benefits encounter, and even those rarely more than once a year, and never for more than a few months at a time. I believe that while there
may be a "lid for every pot," as the saying goes, I am a griddle, and griddles don't have lids. I believe that the signs I see portending love are subconscious wishful thinking on my part, brought on by being as soaked in this One Twu Wuv culture as everybody else. While I'm open to the possibility (it's not a good idea to say "never" to signs and portents), I believe they're not much of anything, really, since I have seen them before and here I am, still single. I believe that if the gods want me mated, which I doubt like hell, they will have to drop said mate pretty much right in my lap with a flashing neon sign that says, "This one is for you, and you are for this one!"
Shyeah, like that'll ever happen. Hasn't in a dozen years, signs be damned, and I see no reason to think it'll change now. And I'm fine with that, since I am not convinced that I can be monogamous, anyway. I haven't really tried since I was in my early 20's, with my ex-husband. I'm not sure I know how. I'm not even sure I want to learn. I've finally gotten content with being single. I'm happy this way. I'd like to stay this way, happily single and not fixated on "being in love" with any person or even the idea of being in a relationship. All of my experiences with love, and I do mean ALL of them, that weren't a family-type or friend-type as opposed to romantic-type love, have been bad. A few started off good at first, then went sharply and rapidly downhill. Most were just a clusterfuck from the beginning, and whether I fought against my own feelings or not never made a damned bit of difference. Only one made it to the year-anniversary and beyond, and that was with my ex husband. Even with him, I vastly prefer the friendship we have now to the oft-times dramatic relationship we had then.
Right now I am celibate, and plan to stay that way. Yeah, I've got about three different guys (no girls, sadly) that I have a more-or-less open invitation for FWB with, but I'm just as content to keep myself to myself. Maybe if I volunteer for CTRF, I'll hook back up with My Hottie, but even that will be just a Faire-fling, as it was before.
So for myself, monogamy is a moot point. For everybody else, I think it's attainable if you want it and are agreed. If you don't, then at least be open and honest about your non-monogamy. After all, it is my firm opinion that the damage from cheating doesn't come from not being monogamous, per se, but from the lies and neglect to the primary partner that make up the cheating. It's cheating because you're breaking your word, not because you're screwing someone else. This is why "emotional affairs," ones that don't involve any sex at all but nonetheless are drenched in lies and neglect, are every bit as damaging as the more traditional variety. That can be a huge problem even in an open relationship, nevermind a monogamous one.
So do I believe in monogamy? Maybe. I believe that it's held up as THE ideal, the one thing that defines a romance, and I'm not sure that's a good idea. I believe it's doable if you work at it, and I believe that it is, in fact, damned hard work. I also believe that non-monogamy is damned hard work, too, and probably trickier to maintain that one-on-one romances.
I also believe that I will never again be faced with having to maintain it. And I'm content with that. In the extraordinarily unlikely event I AM faced with it, I will, as my ex so adroitly puts it, burn that bridge when I get there. I doubt like hell I will ever get there, and if the gods take that as a challenge, then so be it. Experience is experience, and my experience says I am and always will be single. That's fine with me. At heart, I believe monogamy is hard and overrated, and non-monogamy extraordinarily difficult. Neither option appeals to me anymore.
Bast